TIE Expert Panel SETAC): Dr. Miller was invited by the Society of Toxicology and Chemistry (SETAC) to participate on the executive committee for the formation of a SETAC national panel of experts to update TIE procedures for effluents, surface waters, stormwater and sediments. The expert panel convened in Pensacola FL in March 2001, to discuss and review current TIE approaches, formulate approaches for identification of specific classes of toxicants, produce a decision support system for TIE methods, and identify current research needs for TIEs. AQUA-Science submitted five TIE case studies that have been peer-reviewed and accepted for publication in a book that was published in 2005. In addition, AQUA-Science has published two case studies in the latest EPA Toxicity Reduction Evaluation Guidance for Municipal Wastewater Treatment Plants (EPA 833-B-99-002).
USEPA Interlaboratory Whole Effluent Toxicity (WET) Study (USEPA, AMSA): AQUA-Science was selected to participate in the national WET Interlaboratory Variability Study for the following toxicity testing protocols: acute and chronic C. dubia, acute and chronic fathead minnow, and chronic algae (method with and without EDTA). The limited number of participants in this study was selected from across the U.S. based on testing experience, performance in reference toxicant studies, and adherence to stringent QA/QC procedures.
Developed TIE Procedures Using Antibody-Mediated Chemical-Specific Removal Procedures (F-3) to Identify the Role of Diazinon and Chlorpyrifos in Aqueous Matrices (CSWQCB): AQUA-Science developed innovative TIE procedures using antibodies selective for diazinon and chlorpyrifos to permit the identification and confirmation of toxicity caused by the two insecticides in samples of effluent, stormwater and surface waters. This novel process (F-3) received a U.S. patent.
C. dubia Bioassays and TIEs Using F-3 (CSWQCB): AQUA-Science conducted over 90 C. dubia bioassays and 300 ELISA analyses and applied patented F-3 TIE procedures to identify the role of diazinon and chlorpyrifos in the acute and chronic toxicity of California surface waters from Alamo River, Sacramento Slough and Orestimba Creek to C. dubia.
C. dubia Bioassays and TIEs Using F-3 (USFWS): AQUA-Science used a combination of C. dubia toxicity tests, F-3 and ELISA analyses to identify the causes of toxicity of stormwater runoff entering a federal refuge. The procedures conclusively identified diazinon as the cause of the toxicity.
C. dubia Bioassays and TIEs Using F-3 (G. Fred Lee): AQUA-Science used a combination of acute C. dubia bioassays, ELISA analyses, HPLC fractionation, and F-3 to characterize the role of diazinon and chlorpyrifos in the toxicity of Newport Bay tributaries. The studies identified commercial nurseries as the source of the toxicity.
PRIZM Grant Recipient (SFEI): AQUA-Science, the San Francisco Estuary Institute, and the U.C. Davis Department of Entomology were the recipients of a $200K PRIZM grant to develop new TIE procedures for pyrethroid insecticides. As part of this work, an innovative enzyme TIE procedure to identify pyrethroid-caused toxicity was developed and validated. Three peer-reviewed research publications were derived from this work.
Effluent and Surface Water 3-Species Toxicity Tests and TIEs (SRWTP): AQUA-Science conducted quarterly 3-species chronic bioassays on effluent and receiving water for nearly 15 years. Test protocols were developed to assess the contribution of effluent to receiving water toxicity. AQUA-Science designed and conducted innovative TIE studies to identify causes of effluent and receiving water (Sacramento River) toxicity to C. dubia, fathead minnows and algae. The SWQCB commented that the TIE studies were “innovative and state-of-the-art”.
Chronic C. dubia and Algae Toxicity Tests and TIEs (Disney Resort): AQUA-Science conducted chronic C. dubia toxicity tests and TIEs to identify causes of toxicity in resort water discharge. The TIE determined that the toxicity originated from contaminated sampling buckets used by the sampling contractor. Additional TIEs identified zinc as the cause of algal toxicity in a lake attraction and a specific detergent product responsible for C. dubia toxicity in effluent toxicity from washdown operations.
Chronic C. dubia Toxicity Tests and TIEs (City of Davis): AQUA-Science conducted quarterly 3-species bioassays with effluent from two marsh treatment systems. TIEs determined that high TDS was the cause of the toxicity.
Chronic C. dubia Toxicity Tests and TIEs (Inland Empire Utilities Agency): AQUA-Science conducted approximately 30 chronic C. dubia bioassays and over 200 ELISA analyses to determine optimal treatment plant operating conditions to remove organophosphorous (OP) insecticides, diazinon and chlorpyrifos, for 3 POTWs in the Chino Basin. TIEs were conducted to identify and confirm the role of the two OPs and pyrethroids in the effluent toxicity.
Acute and Chronic C. dubia Toxicity Tests and TIEs (CCCSD): AQUA-Science conducted approximately 40 acute and chronic C. dubia toxicity tests and ELISA analyses on final effluent. Phase I, II and III TIEs were performed that identified diazinon and chlorpyrifos as the causes of toxicity. The TIE was included as a Case Study in the EPA Effluent Toxicity Guidance Manual.
Chronic C. dubia Bioassays on Receiving Waters (Larry Walker): AQUA-Science conducted chronic C. dubia bioassays on receiving waters in Sonoma County impacted by municipal effluent. A study protocol was designed and implemented to assess toxicity in high TDS waters.
Acute and Chronic C. dubia Bioassays and TIEs (ACME Fill): AQUA-Science conducted approximately 75 acute and chronic C. dubia bioassays on landfill leachate, and conducted TIEs that identified TDS as the cause of toxicity. Testing procedures and a toxicity model was developed to assess leachate toxicity to C. dubia in the presence of high TDS.
Acute C. dubia Bioassays and TIEs (City of Vallejo): Acute C. dubia bioassays and Phase I, II and III TIEs were conducted to identify the causes of toxicity in municipal effluent. The TIEs incorporated a weight-of-evidence approach that involved chemical fingerprinting, chemical analysis and statistical procedures. It was shown that diazinon was the primary cause of the effluent toxicity.
C. dubia and Fathead Minnow Toxicity Tests and TIEs (USS-Posco Industries): Flow-through acute toxicity tests conducted on a steel mill effluent that was discharged into the Delta detected toxicity to fathead minnows and C. dubia. An innovative TIE approach was used that included developing toxicity models for over 30 process chemicals used in the facility and fingerprinting the effluent and process chemicals using HPLC elution profiles. The TIE showed that a single process chemical (mineral oil defoamer) was responsible for the toxicity. The effluent toxicity was eliminated when use of this chemical in the facility was discontinued.
Chronic C. dubia, Fathead Minnow and Algae Bioassays and TIEs (Air Products). AQUA-Science conducted 3-species toxicity tests and TIEs on a stormwater discharge from a hydrogen manufacturing facility. Identified zinc from a nearby refinery as the source of toxicity to the test species.
Fathead Minnow TIE Procedures (CVRWQCB): AQUA-Science developed procedures for identification of pathogen-related toxicity (PRT). Tasks included identification of cause(s) and procedures to control PRT, including sterilization, antibiotic addition, and improved hygiene in test chambers.
Development of Algae Test System (City of Los Angeles): AQUA-Science assisted in development and calibration of an algae test system to reliably measure effluent toxicity. Conducted Phase I and II TIEs to identify the causes of effluent toxicity from two treatment plants to algae. Ammonia and non-polar organics were identified as cause(s) of toxicity.
Algal TIE Procedures (SRWQCB): AQUA-Science developed algal TIE procedures, including determining tolerance of TIE reagents, developing Phase II TIE fractionation procedures, and developing an algae micro-assay for SPE and HPLC fractions. This work has been published in a peer-reviewed book on TIE methodology.
Algal Toxicity Tests and TIEs (City of Sacramento): AQUA-Science conducted chronic algal toxicity tests and developed innovative TIE procedures, including SPE and HPLC column elution profiles, to identify and characterize algal toxicity in urban creeks in the Sacramento area. Identified the role of the herbicides, simazine and diuron, in the toxicity of stormwater runoff from Arcade Creek, Chicken Ranch Slough and Strong Ranch Slough.
Echinoderm Toxicity Test and TIE (CCCSD): AQUA-Science developed and published TIE procedures to identify causes of effluent toxicity to Echinoderms (S. purpuratus and D. excentricus). The TIE identified copper as the toxicant.